As we strive to modernize our Army, we still hold onto ancient and archaic systems that just need to be revamped. The Army structure and methodology changed from a strategic cold war way of thinking to a more tactical expeditionary way of thinking. For the longest time we focused on the ‘inevitable’ war in eastern Europe against the former Soviet Union, still employing tactics from WWII. Now, the Army is changing rapidly to adapt to the global changes. We are facing the global threat of Islamic radicalism, taking the fight to the middle east in Iraq. The Army system reminds me of backwoods democrats from West Virginia, they don’t know why they vote democrat, they just know that’s what grand pappy did and he would roll over in his grave if they voted any different. Never mind about the issues or what the party stands for, and you can’t tell them any different. The Army will continue to do things because that’s just the way it’s always been done. We still have equipment assigned to our unit that was used during WWII and earlier. It shouldn’t have taken a ‘War on Terrorism’ to change the Army, we should have been adapting all along. But changes take time and more importantly, money. If Congress had not cut our funding over the years, we could have modernized many things in the Army before the onset of the War on Terror. So here we are spending much of the defense bill to update the Army from ancient times. I believe this ultimately effects the enlisted ranks of the Army. Just look at the recent ‘scandal’ at Walter Reed Hospital, Building 81, where us po enlisted folks go to stay during rehab. Officers tried to cover it up with reports that everything is fine, had that been the officers care facility, it would have been state of the art. Don’t get me wrong, enlisted Soldier care has come a long way, but it still has a long way to go. Which leads me to my next thought, America still holds dear to it’s archaic Army social structure.
The most prominent base for the Army’s social structure comes from the medieval feudal system. This system separates officer and enlisted ranks into a two class system. Just read this article in Time magazine:
After two months of closed-door hearings, a six-man investigating board delivered its report on the cause & cure of the Army's "caste system." Its 53 pages and 10,000 words boiled down to a diagnosis which surprised no one: the roots of the disease were 1) poor leadership; 2) an excessive official and social gap between officers and men.
Most of the witnesses' fire had been concentrated on the small body of officers "inherently unqualified or inadequately trained," who popped up inevitably in an Army swollen fortyfold in wartime. As a remedy, the board recommended a major overhaul of the officer corps. Most significant repairs: promotion by merit instead of seniority; prompt dismissal or demotion of incompetents.
As a further precaution, the board outlined a series of reforms to assure enlisted men "more definite protection from the arbitrary acts of superiors." The Army's rickety military-justice machinery would be modified to include enlisted men as members of courts-martial; sentences would be progressively stiffened for higher ranks. To check up on abuses, the inspector general's office would be beefed up with additional investigators.
Several new bridges were thrown across the officer-enlisted-man gap. Some of them were primarily economic: quarters and travel allowances for all ranks, cumulative furlough time and terminal-leave pay for enlisted men as well as officers. Others were designed to wipe out needless social discriminations, off-duty saluting, the use of such archaic phrases as "officer's ladies and enlisted men's wives."
Unanimously, the board agreed: "There is a need for a new philosophy in the military order: a full recognition of the dignity of man."
This article was written in 1946, but you can see how not much has changed since. I think the Army should research and make changes to the current social system. While I believe tradition is important, it shouldn’t stand in the way of improvement. Our rank structure could stand an overhaul, perhaps a multi-tiered rank structure or just one rank structure, but the Army is too busy lately to focus that much attention on that, and the ones who make the decisions are wearing the shiny stuff looking down on us lowly grunts. So, I will continue to do the jobs of 2 officers while enjoying the enlisted pay and benefits. NCOs should be given more credit and responsibility in units. This leads me to another thought about America’s fetish with Officers. You already know that Officers do all the work and thinking in the Army, as well as provide all the heroics during combat, while enlisted Soldiers fill sandbags and sit scared waiting for their officer to guide them. Well, I’ve rambled on enough, as you have read, and as you can tell I some issues. I’ll deal with them and drive on as I always have, dealing with the system, and doing my job to the utmost.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment